Bagels By The Bay Menu (2025 Update)
Bagels By The Bay is a charming breakfast and brunch spot located in Staten Island. With a menu featuring a variety of cream cheese and egg sandwiches, as well as a selection of beverages including coffee, tea, and juices, this place is a must-visit for bagel lovers. Customers rave about the friendly and welcoming customer service, making them feel like family. The fresh and delightful bagels paired with hot coffee create a cozy breakfast experience that keeps patrons coming back for more. The pastrami sandwich and French toast bagel are standout items that receive high praise for their delicious flavors and generous portions. Bagels By The Bay is a hidden gem that promises a satisfying meal in a warm and inviting atmosphere.
Beverages
Coffee
Tea
Flavored Herbal Tea
Hot Chocolate
French Vanilla Cappuccino
24 oz. Cup Iced Coffee
20 oz. Soda
Bottled Water
Snapple
Small Tropicana Juice
Large Tropicana Juice
Quart Tropicana Juice
Half Gallon Tropicana Orange Juice
Espresso
Pure Leaf Iced Tea
Assorted flavors
Nesquick or Yoohoo Chocolate Milk
Assorted flavors
Monster Energy Drink
Red Bull Energy Drink
Regular or Sugar Free 8 oz.
Muscle Milk (vanilla flavor only)
Vanilla flavor only
Bagel and Plain Cream Cheese
Bagel and Butter
Bagel with Plain Cream Cheese and Jelly
Bagel with Butter and Jelly
Bagel with Flavored Cream Cheese Spread
Bagel with Plain Cream Cheese and Fresh Lox
Salmon.
Bagel with Butter and Fresh Lox
Salmon.
Bagel with Plain Cream Cheese and Bacon Sandwich
Bagel with Plain Cream Cheese and Ham Sandwich
Bagel with Plain Cream Cheese and Turkey Sandwich
Bagel with Butter and Bacon Sandwich
Bagel with Butter and Ham Sandwich
Bagel with Butter and Turkey Sandwich
BLT
Hummus Sandwich
on bagel/roll
Grilled Cheese Sandwich
American cheese.
1 lb. of Flavored Cream Cheese Spread
1 lb. of Hummus
Single Bagel
With no toppings.
Cream Cheese Sandwiches
Egg Sandwiches
Egg Sandwich (two extra large eggs)
Egg(Two extra large eggs) and Cheese Sandwich
Egg (Two extra large eggs), Ham with Cheese Sandwich
Egg (Two extra large eggs), Bacon with Cheese Sandwich
Sausage, Egg (Two extra large eggs) and Cheese Sandwich
Salami, Egg (Two extra large eggs) and Cheese Sandwich
Bologna, Egg (Two extra large eggs) and Cheese Sandwich
Steak, Egg (Two extra large eggs) and Cheese Sandwich
Pastrami, Egg (Two extra large eggs) and Cheese Sandwich
Potato and Egg (Two extra large eggs) Sandwich
Egg (Two extra large eggs), Turkey with Cheese Sandwich
Potato, Egg (Two extra large eggs) and Cheese Sandwich
Turkey Bacon, Egg (Two extra large eggs) and Cheese
Hero Egg Sandwich
Hero Egg and Cheese Sandwich
Hero Egg, Bacon and Cheese Sandwich
Hero Egg, Ham and Cheese Sandwich
Hero Egg, Turkey and Cheese Sandwich
Hero Sausage, Egg and Cheese Sandwich
Hero Salami, Egg and Cheese Sandwich
Hero Bologna, Egg and Cheese Sandwich
Hero Steak, Egg and Cheese Sandwich
Hero Pastrami, Egg and Cheese Sandwich
Hero Potato and Egg Sandwich
Hero Potato, Egg and Cheese Sandwich
Hero Turkey Bacon, Egg and Cheese Sandwich
Hero Egg Sandwiches
Breakfast Platters
3 Eggs, choice of Bacon, Ham or turkey, Cheese, and Home Fries Platter
Served with buttered white, whole wheat or rye bread.
Sausage, 3 Eggs, Cheese and Home Fries Platter
Served with buttered white, whole wheat or rye bread.
Turley Bacon, 3 Eggs, Cheese and Home Fries Platter
Served with buttered white, whole wheat or rye bread.
5 Pancakes Platter (No toast)
Served with syrup on the side.
Pancakes and Bacon Platter
Served with buttered white, whole wheat or rye bread.
Pancakes and Ham Platter
Served with buttered white, whole wheat or rye bread.
Pancakes and Turkey Platter
Served with buttered white, whole wheat or rye bread.
Egg Omelet with Cheese and Toast
Served with buttered white, whole wheat or rye bread.
Western Omelet Platter
Served with buttered white, whole wheat or rye bread and home fries.
Vegetable Omelet Platter
Green pepper, tomatoes and onions home fries. Served with buttered white, whole wheat or rye bread.
3 Eggs, Turkey, Cheese and Home Fries Platter
Served with buttered white, whole wheat or rye bread.
3 Eggs, Bacon, Cheese and Hashbrowns Platter
Served with buttered white, whole wheat or rye bread.
3 Eggs, Ham, Cheese and Hashbrowns Platter
Served with buttered white, whole wheat or rye bread.
3 Eggs, Turkey, Cheese and Hashbrowns Platter
Served with buttered white, whole wheat or rye bread.
Home Fries
French Fries
Bagel
Half Dozen Bagels
Does not include rainbow, cheddar & jalapeno or french toast bagels. Additional charges may apply. Please indicate bagel flavor quantities in the special instructions. With 1 free bagel.
Dozen Bagels
Rainbow Bagel (Plain, nothing on it)
French Toast Bagel (Plain, nothing on it)
Cheddar Cheese & Jalapeno Bagel (Plain, nothing on it)
Bagels
Muffins
Yogurt Muffin
Nothing on it
Toasted Muffin with Butter
Toasted Muffin with Butter and Jelly (Grape)
Grilled Chicken Ceasar Salad
Crisp romaine lettuce topped with our marinated grilled chicken breast, baked seasoned croutons, sliced onions, grated Parmesan cheese and a classic Caesar dressing.
Fresh Mozzarella and Tomato Salad
Fresh water mozzarella, sliced tomatoes, red roasted peppers, black olives on a bed of crisp lettuce and choice of dressing.
Garden of Eden Salad
A bed of mixed lettuce, sliced tomatoes, cucumber slices, onions, sweet, hot and roasted peppers, green and black olives, fresh backed seasoned croutons and choice of dressing.
Antipasto Salad
Red roasted peppers, fresh mozzarella, thinly sliced prosciutto, Genoa salami, provolone cheese, sun-dried tomatoes, green and black olives on bed of crisp lettuce, choice of dressing.
Tossed Salad
A bed of mixed lettuce, fresh sliced tomatoes, cucumber slices, fresh baked seasoned croutons and choice of dressing.
Mediterranean Salad
On a crisp bed of lettuce sliced tomatoes, firm cucumber slices, Bermuda onions, sliced hard-boiled egg, crunchy walnuts, sweet raisins and choice of dressing.
Salads
Panini
Vegeterian Delight Panini
Eggplant, fresh mozzarella, roasted pepper, lettuce, tomato, onion, olive oil, vinegar and oregano.
Roast Beef Panini
Roasted beef with Swiss cheese, caramelized onion, tomatoes and Russian dressing.
Tiny Bikini Panini
Oven roasted turkey mozzarella cheese,roasted pepper and sun-dried tomato, pesto.
The Italiano Panini
Grilled chicken, roasted pepper, fresh mozzarella, pesto.
The Godfather Part II Panini
Prosciutto, fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers, tomatoes, lettuce, pesto dressing.
Chicken Cordon Bleu Panini
Choice of baked or fried chicken cutlet topped with Virginia ham slices, melted mozzarella cheese and your choice of dressing.
Pastrami Supreme Panini
Hot pastrami, crisp bacon and melted Swiss cheese with spicy Board's Head mustard.
Create Your Own Panini
Choice of any one meat and any one cheese with any topping.
Turkey and Cheddar Wrap
With lettuce, tomatoes and onions.
Italiano with Sweet Pepper Wrap
With lettuce, tomatoes and onions.
Italiano with Hot Peppers Wrap
With lettuce, tomatoes and onions.
Italiano with Roasted Peppers Wrap
With lettuce, tomatoes and onions.
Chicken Wrap
With your choice of chicken and lettuce, tomatoes and onions.
Virginia Ham and Swiss Wrap
With lettuce, tomatoes and onions.
Roast Beef, Bacon and Cheese Wrap
With lettuce, tomatoes and onions.
Salsalito Turkey and Pepper Turkey Wrap
Pepper jack cheese with lettuce, tomatoes and onions.
Cajun Roast Beaf and American Cheese Wrap
With lettuce, tomatoes and onions.
Black Forest Ham and Cheddar Wrap
With lettuce, tomatoes and onions.
The Chuck Chillout Wrap
Caesar chicken and fresh mozzarella. With lettuce, tomatoes and onions.
Chicken Salad Wrap
With lettuce, tomatoes and onions.
Tuna Salad Wrap
With lettuce, tomatoes and onions.
Egg Salad Wrap
With lettuce, tomatoes and onions.
Signature Wraps
Lunch Appetizer
Lunch Chicken Fingers
With french fries.
Lunch Onion Ring
Lunch French Fries
Lunch Large French Fries with Cheese and Gravy
With melted fresh mozzarella cheese and gravy on side.
Lunch Chicken Salad
Comes on either a roll, bagel or bread.
Lunch Tuna Salad
Lunch Egg Salad
Homemade chicken salad by the pound
Homemade chicken salad
Homemade tuna salad by the pound
homemade tuna salad
Homemade Egg salad
homemade egg salad
Lunch Home Made Salad
Lunch Menu
The Turkey Melt Lunch
Hot oven roasted turkey, crisp bacon, melted American cheese, lettuce, tomato and choice of dressing.
Lunch Chicken Fantastic
Breast of chicken cutlet, crisp bacon, melted American cheese, lettuce, tomato, and choice of dressing.
Lunch Philly Cheese Steak
Hot roast beef, brown gravy and melted American cheese with peppers and onions on toasted garlic bread.
Lunch Pastrami Supreme
Hot pastrami, crisp bacon and melted Swiss cheese with spicy Boars Head mustard.
Lunch Classic Reuben
Hot corned beef, melted Swiss cheese, sauerkraut, boars head spicy mustard on rye bread.
Lunch Texas Melt
Hot BBQ chicken breast, melted American cheese, smothered in hickory smoked BBQ sauce on toasted garlic bread.
Lunch Buffalo Stampede
Hot chicken cutlet topped with melted mozzarella cheese, blue cheese dressing, and a dash of Tabasco sauce.
The Terminator Lunch
Oven roasted turkey breast, hot roast beef, melted mozzarella cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, roasted peppers, choice of dressing.
The Italiano Lunch
Sweet cappy ham, Genoa salami, provolone cheese topped with onions, lettuce, tomatoes, hot and or sweet peppers, oil, vinegar and oregano.
The Godfather Part I Lunch
Hot capicola, fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers topped with onions, lettuce, tomato, oil, vinegar, salt, pepper and oregano.
The Robert Deniro Lunch
Marinated chicken cutlet in sun dried tomatoes and balsamic vinegar, topped with fresh mozzarella, red onions and Romaine lettuce.
The Al Pacino Lunch
Marinated lemon chicken cutlet, fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers topped with onions, lettuce, tomato, and Caesar dressing.
Lunch Meatball Explosion
German style meatballs, with brown gravy, melted American yellow cheese, topped with fried onions on toasted garlic bread.
Lunch Vegetarian Delight
Fried eggplant slices, fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers, lettuce, tomato, onions, oil, vinegar and oregano.
The Kim Basinger Lunch
Our homemade tuna salad topped with sliced red onions and hot cherry pepper slices.
The Frank Sinatra Lunch
Boar's Head peppered turkey piled high on toasted garlic bread topped with cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato, sliced pickles and Your Way sauce.
Lunch Chicken Cordon Bleu
Choice of baked or fried chicken cutlet topped with Virginia ham slices, melted mozzarella cheese and your choice of dressing.
The Rosebank Special Lunch
Oven roasted turkey breast, crispy bacon, sliced Swiss cheese, crumbled hard-boiled egg, lettuce, tomato, sliced onion, and Thousand Island dressing.
The Twin Towers Lunch
Thinly sliced Boar's Head lean corned beef and pastrami, Swiss cheese, sliced pickle topped with spicy mustard.
Lunch the Stinger
Hormel DiLusso salami, slicing pepperoni, Boar's Head boiled ham, sliced provolone topped with hot cherry peppers, onions and balsamic vinegar.
Lunch Monte Cristo
Boar's Head brand #1 boiled ham, Oven Gold roasted turkey breast, melted Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato and Russian dressing.
Lunch Chicken Cutlet Special
Baked or fried chicken cutlets, fried eggplant slices, red roasted peppers, fresh mozzarella, lettuce, tomato, and balsamic vinegar.
Lunch Lamb Gyro
Served on Greek bread, with lettuce, tomatoes, onions and tzatziki sauce.
Lunch Cheeseburger Deluxe
Served with lettuce, tomatoes, onion, pickles, and french fries.
Chicken Salad Sandwich Lunch Special
On Mondays only
Roast Beef Sandwich Lunch Special
On Wednesdays Only.
Pastrami Sandwich Lunch Special
On Thursdays Only.
Corned Beef Sandwich Lunch Special
On Thursdays Only.
Tuna Sandwich Lunch Special
On Fridays Only.
Egg salad Sandwich Lunch Special
On Tuesday only.
Lunch Specials
Cold Cuts
choice of Boars Head Peppermill Turkey Or Ham,Salami,Balogna,Pepperoni,Overngold turkey Per Lb
Choice of Boars Head
Choice of Boars head Roast Beef Or Pastrami Or Prosciutto Or Hot Capocollo Or Sopressata Or Corned Beef Or Honey Turkey
Choice of Boars Head Yellow American. White American Cheese
Choice Of Boars head Mozzerella, Cheddar,Swiss,Pepperjack,Meunster,Provolone,Fresh Mozerella Cheese
Bagels By The Bay Special
Choice of Turkey,Ham,Salami,Balogna,Peppermill Turkey, and your choice of one type of cheese. Includes Mayo,Chesse,Lettuce,Tomato.Onions,