Welcome to Bagels By The Bay, a delightful gem nestled at 1235 Bay St, Staten Island, NY. Known for its inviting atmosphere and fresh offerings, this breakfast and brunch haven quickly captures the hearts of locals and visitors alike.

As you step into this cozy establishment, the warm greetings from the friendly staff set the tone for a memorable dining experience. Customers rave about the service, noting how each visit feels like being welcomed into a family kitchen. It’s this unique blend of outstanding hospitality and delicious food that keeps patrons coming back for more.

The menu boasts an impressive array of breakfast and lunch items, with an emphasis on freshness and quality. One highlight is their delectable bagels, acclaimed for their perfectly baked texture that complements any spread. Visitors like Desmen S. can't get enough, describing Bagels By The Bay as their weekend staple, thanks to the incredible selection and comforting vibes.

For those looking for something heartier, their paninis are a must-try. Take, for instance, the Roast Beef Panini, featuring savory roasted beef paired with Swiss cheese and caramelized onions — it’s a flavor explosion that will satisfy even the most discerning palate. The Chicken Cordon Bleu Panini offers a delightful twist with crispy chicken and Virginia ham, while the Godfather Part II Panini showcases prosciutto and fresh mozzarella, bringing a taste of Italy right to Staten Island.

Need a light lunch? The homemade salads are prepared with care, from the creamy tuna salad to the rich chicken salad, served on your choice of a bagel, roll, or bread. Priced reasonably, these dishes reflect a commitment to quality without breaking the bank — a sentiment echoed by visitors like David O., who appreciates the value offered here.

No visit is complete without a sweet touch. The French Toast Bagel, praised by Amanda W., is a delectable treat, boasting a fluffy texture and delightful glaze — perfect for those with a sweet tooth.

In the bustling culinary landscape of Staten Island, Bagels By The Bay stands out, not just for their food but for their unwavering dedication to customer satisfaction. With every bite, you’re reminded of the warmth and love poured into each dish. This charming spot not only earns a place in our hearts but also solidifies its reputation as the ideal venue for a fantastic breakfast or brunch.